Jade Cargills return at WWE Elimination Chamber 2025 was nothing short of explosive, as she stormed back onto the scene to take out Naomithe woman revealed as her mystery attacker. But while the storyline is playing out on TV, the real drama is happening backstage, with conflicting reports on whether Cargill was actually injured in the first place.
For months, rumors swirled about Cargills time away, with some in WWE reportedly questioning the legitimacy of her injuryespecially since WWE had initially denied her time off during the holiday season. Now, Mike Johnson of PWInsider has doubled down on his belief that Cargills injury was a work, pointing out that she was able to travel, work on Hollywood projects, and even train at the Performance Center while supposedly sidelined.
But Sean Ross Sapp of Fightful Select isnt buying it. Responding on Twitter/X, Sapp claimed that if the injury was fake, then WWEs entire medical team, creative team, and even Cargills close friends were workedwhich seems unlikely.
With such strong takes on both sides, the truth remains murky. Was Cargill legitimately injured, or was this all part of a larger play to keep her off TV? Either way, the uncertainty only adds another layer of intrigue to her high-profile return and ongoing feud with Naomi.
Do you think Jade Cargill was actually injured, or was this all part of a long-term plan? Please share your thoughts and feedback in the comment section below.
