Brighton 0-0 Nottingham Forest (AET 3-4 pens): Player ratings as Seagulls crash out on penalties

Brighton were edged out of a ruthlessly tight FA Cup quarter-final on penalties after a goalless two hours at home to Nottingham Forest on Saturday afternoon.

The weight of Saturday's occasion hung heavy over a stodgy opening 90 minutes. Nottingham Forest haven't lifted the FA Cup in 66 years - the last time they made it to the final, Brighton boss Fabian Hurzeler wasn't even born. The Seagulls have never won football's oldest cup competition.

The two sides managed to combine for just four shots across the entire opening 45 minutes. Forest had been 3-0 up at the interval when Brighton travelled to the City Ground in February, infamously racking up seven unanswered goals against their porous visitors on that historic day.

Hurzeler set the notebook he had used to plan for that fixture on fire in a slightly cultish ceremony in front of his squad after that defeat. The controlled burn sparked a hot streak for Brighton, who bounded into Saturday's quarter-final on the back of six wins from their last seven games.

Forest have been less convincing over the intervening eight weeks and lined up at the Amex without a fleet of regular starters. It showed. In the absence of top scorer Chris Wood, the visitors didn't offer a great deal of attacking threat, but managed to muzzle their hosts with a typically organised setup, dispensing with any attacking width to stuff the middle of the pitch with as many red shirts as the laws of the game permitted.

The stitching of both sides belatedly began to loosen in the second half, with Brighton growing into the ascendancy. However, it was Forest who won a penalty shortly after the hour-mark as Elliot Anderson tumbled over a sliding tackle from Kaoru Mitoma. After a VAR consultation, on-pitch referee Peter Bankes adjudged that Anderson had initiated the contact.

An air of hesitancy and angst was riddled throughout the entirety of the contest, which crawled into extra time with the game still resolutely goalless.

Brighton substitute Diego Gomez forced an impressive stop from Forest's in-form Matz Sels and Joao Pedro had a late tap-in rightly ruled out for a clear offside, but a penalty shootout felt all but inevitable long before Bankes blew his whistle.

Gomez proved to be just as wasteful in the shootout. After consecutive misses from his teammate Jack Hinshelwood and Forest's Neco Williams, Brighton's winter recruit blasted his powerful effort straight onto Sels' glove. Ryan Yates held his nerve, sending the ball squirming through Bart Verbruggen's clutches to send Forest into the semi-finals.

Penalty shootout

• 1-0 - Joao Pedro (Brighton) - SCORED
• 1-1 - Elliot Anderson (Nottingham Forest) - SCORED
• 2-1 - Brajan Gruda (Brighton) - SCORED
• 2-2 - Callum Hudson-Odoi (Nottingham Forest) - SCORED
• 2-2 - Jack Hinshelwood (Brighton) - MISSED
• 2-2 - Neco Williams (Nottingham Forest) - MISSED
• 2-2 - Diego Gomez (Brighton) - MISSED
• 2-3 - Nikola Milenkovic (Nottingham Forest) - SCORED
• 3-3 - Lewis Dunk (Brighton) - SCORED
• 3-4 - Ryan Yates (Nottingham Forest) - SCORED

Brighton player ratings (4-2-3-1)

*Ratings provided by FotMob*

Subs not used: Thomas McGill (GK), Charlie Tasker, Eiran Cashin, Matthew O'Riley.

Nottingham Forest player ratings (4-2-3-1)

*Ratings provided by FotMob*

Subs not used: Carlos Miguel (GK), Alex Moreno, Harry Toffolo, Willy Boly, Ibrahim Sangare.

Player of the match - Bart Verbruggen (Brighton)

READ THE LATEST FA CUP NEWS, PREVIEWS & RATINGS HERE